How to File a Moving Damage Claim (and Actually Get Paid)

Need a moving company damage claim letter? Write it free and preview it before you pay.
File Your Damage Claim NowHow to File a Moving Damage Claim (and Actually Get Paid)
Moving is stressful enough without finding that your $2,000 OLED TV has a cracked screen or your antique dresser is missing a leg.
When you hire a moving company, you pay for more than labor. You pay for your belongings to arrive intact. If the movers break something, they are legally responsible for it.
The problem is that many moving companies make the claims process so difficult that people give up. They use confusing "valuation" terms and strict 9-month deadlines to avoid paying.
If your belongings were damaged in a move, here is the process for getting a fair settlement.
Step 1: Understand Your "Valuation" Coverage
Before you file, find out which coverage applies. There are two main types:
- Released Value Protection (The "Free" Kind): This is the basic coverage required by federal law. It pays $0.60 per pound per item. If they break a 100-pound TV worth $2,000, they owe you $60. It is poor coverage, but it is the default if you did not pay for an upgrade.
- Full Value Protection (The "Paid" Kind): If you paid for this, the movers are responsible for the item's "replacement value." They must repair it, replace it with a similar item, or pay you its current market value in cash.
Even with the basic coverage, file a claim. In many states, movers are still liable for full value if they were "grossly negligent" (for example, dropping a box from a second-story balcony).
Step 2: Document the Damage Immediately
The most common mistake is waiting a week to unpack. The movers will then say the damage happened after they left.
- Take photos and video: Take close-ups of the damage and wide shots showing the item in its box or location.
- Keep everything: Keep the broken items and the packing materials. The insurer may want to inspect them.
- Find your "Bill of Lading": This is the contract you signed. Look for the inventory sheet where the movers recorded each item's condition before the move. If they did not note a scratch on the dresser then and it has one now, that is your proof.
Step 3: Check for "Hidden" Damage
Inspect your house, not just your belongings.
- Are there gouges in the hardwood floors?
- Did they scrape paint off the hallway walls?
- Is there a dent in the front door? Movers are responsible for property damage as well as cargo damage. Photograph these problems before you repair them.
Step 4: Submit the Formal Claim
Most moving companies have a claims form on their website. Fill it out, but do not stop there. Claims submitted through these forms often get no response.
Right after submitting the form, send a formal demand letter. This starts the legal deadlines. Under federal law (for interstate moves), movers must acknowledge your claim within 30 days and offer a settlement or denial within 120 days.
Hiring a lawyer for a $1,000 claim does not make sense. You can use howtowritea.com to generate a professional demand letter for $9 to $29.
The letter includes:
- Your move date and "Job Number."
- An itemized list of damaged items with their weights and estimated replacement costs.
- Photos of the damage.
- A demand for a settlement within a specific timeframe.
- A statement that you will escalate to the FMCSA (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration) and the Better Business Bureau if the claim isn't handled fairly.
Step 5: Negotiate the "Depreciation"
The moving company will try to pay the "used" value of your items. If they break a 5-year-old couch, they may offer $100.
Push back. With Full Value Protection, they must restore you to your "pre-loss condition." If $100 cannot buy a similar couch in the same condition, the offer is too low. Show replacement prices you found on sites like eBay or Facebook Marketplace.
Step 6: Use the "Nuclear Options"
If the moving company ignores you or makes an unreasonably low offer (like a $20 check for a broken fridge), you have three more options:
- The FMCSA Complaint: If your move crossed state lines, file a complaint at
move.gov. The government tracks these complaints, and too many can cost a mover its license. - The "Arbitration" Clause: Check your contract. Most movers are required to participate in an arbitration program, where a neutral third party decides the claim. It costs much less than court.
- Credit Card Chargeback: If you paid with a credit card, you can dispute part of the charge as "services not as described" (you paid for a safe move and your belongings were damaged). Movers tend to respond quickly to this.
Next Steps
Moving companies count on customers being too tired after a move to pursue $400 or $800. Delay is part of how they avoid paying.
Document the damage, keep the boxes, and use howtowritea.com to send a formal demand. A mover that sees you are organized and know the federal regulations is much more likely to pay your claim.